Thursday, August 18, 2011

Coping with chaos -- with false certainty

I was looking today for a paper -- allegedly published in Science earlier this year -- reporting the results of a re-run of the famous Robert Axelrod open competition for algorithms playing the Prisoner's Dilemma. In that competition, the simple TIT-FOR-TAT strategy -- start out the first time cooperating, and then afterward do whatever your opponent did in the preceding round -- won out easily over much more complex strategies. The twist on the new competition (as I've been told), is to allow copying strategies so players can explicitly mimic the behaviour of others they see doing well. Apparently, some very simple (mindless) copying strategies won this new competition, showing how blind copying can be a very effective strategy in competitive games.

But I must have had the wrong reference, because I didn't find the paper in the 8 April 2011 issue of Science. I'll track it down and post on it soon -- this kind of thing obviously has huge implications for strategies used in financial markets, where copying may well out-perform allegedly more sophisticated techniques. But I stumbled over something else in that issue of Science that is worth mentioning, even if briefly (as I don't have access to Science and haven't yet been able to read the full paper).

The paper is entitled Coping with Chaos: How Disordered Contexts Promote Stereotyping and Discrimination. It reports the results of experiments in which two psychologists, Diederik Stapel and Siegwart Lindenberg, tested how the level of environmental uncertainty might influence the tendency of volunteers to make judgments on the basis of simple stereotypes. They took advantage of a rail strike in Utrecht -- during which train stations became much more littered and disordered. Here's the abstract (at least):
Being the victim of discrimination can have serious negative health- and quality-of-life–related consequences. Yet, could being discriminated against depend on such seemingly trivial matters as garbage on the streets? In this study, we show, in two field experiments, that disordered contexts (such as litter or a broken-up sidewalk and an abandoned bicycle) indeed promote stereotyping and discrimination in real-world situations and, in three lab experiments, that it is a heightened need for structure that mediates these effects (number of subjects: between 40 and 70 per experiment). These findings considerably advance our knowledge of the impact of the physical environment on stereotyping and discrimination and have clear policy implications: Diagnose environmental disorder early and intervene immediately.
This is interesting in this limited context of discrimination and how the orderliness of physical environments might influence it, but the effect described seems in fact to be far more general -- it reflects a human longing for order and simplicity whenever faced with too much uncertainty. On the same point, another notable study from 2008 (also in Science) by Jennifer Whitson and Adam Galinsky showed how uncertainty and loss of control makes people more likely to see fictitious patterns in random data. In brief, they had a set of volunteers plays some competitive games in which they could influence how much the volunteers felt in control. For example, they could induce feelings of loss of control and uncertainty by eradicating any link between the players' actions and the outcomes. Then they tested these people on totally random data sets (some looking like stock market time series) to see how much they would perceive fictitious patterns in the random data. Those primed more strongly with the "loss of control and uncertainty" feelings were significantly more likely to see patterns where there were none -- grasping, apparently, for some kind of order in a perplexing world. The paper is available in full at the link I gave above, but here's the abstract:
We present six experiments that tested whether lacking control increases illusory pattern perception, which we define as the identification of a coherent and meaningful interrelationship among a set of random or unrelated stimuli. Participants who lacked control were more likely to perceive a variety of illusory patterns, including seeing images in noise, forming illusory correlations in stock market information, perceiving conspiracies, and developing superstitions. Additionally, we demonstrated that increased pattern perception has a motivational basis by measuring the need for structure directly and showing that the causal link between lack of control and illusory pattern perception is reduced by affirming the self. Although these many disparate forms of pattern perception are typically discussed as separate phenomena, the current results suggest that there is a common motive underlying them.
This seems to fit in very well with the experiments of Stapel and Lindenberg. It reminds me of what Nietzsche said long ago:
"Danger, disquiet, anxiety attend the unknown — the first instinct is to eliminate these distressing states. First principle: any explanation is better than none.”
 Indeed, this seems to be a very general topic on which a great deal is known from psychology. Galinsky's web site lists a forthcoming article which appears to be a review of sorts. I look forward to reading that.

Also worth a read is this feature in Wired, which discusses some related experiments. Curiously, the article quotes Christina Romer, the former chairwoman of President Obama’s Council of Economic Advisers, on economic uncertainty and it's influence on the opinions of "respected analysts" about where things are going. This was from December 2010:
One sign of heightened macroeconomic uncertainty is that the forecasts of respected analysts are all over the map. According to the Survey of Professional Forecasters conducted by the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, the difference between the highest and the lowest forecasts of unemployment a year from now is about twice as large as it was before the crisis. And forecasters’ reported uncertainty about their longer-run forecasts has shown no sign of improving over the last year. If professional forecasters are unsure of the future, businesses and consumers certainly are as well.
Then again, this spread in forecasts is a healthy thing. Things were by no means "more certain" before the crisis, it only seemed that way to an army of "respected forecasters" who found comfort in saying pretty much the same thing as everyone else.

33 comments:

  1. witness the current mania, extending from Cramer to the heads of major mutual funds and hedge funds, whereby "high frequency trading" is seen as the source of the recent volatility in markets. Bob Pisani pointed out on his blog last Friday that the general attitude was, "I'm a genius, I can't possibly be losing this much money with my decisions, there must be a cause for my losses in this very chaotic market environment, it can't be me". Companies like Nanex are widely quoted as having found meaningful patterns in the order streams of various electronic exchanges, along with declarations that they've found algorithms, like "Disruptor", that are somehow taking everyone's money. This is superstition and illusory pattern finding writ large, and quite consistent with the discussion above.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is called "Apophenia" -- seeing meaningful patterns in random data

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apophenia

    ReplyDelete
  3. Just an update, the paper "Coping with Chaos: How Disordered Contexts Promote Stereotyping and Discrimination" was retracted in Nov 11. More information can be found here: http://www.sciencemag.org.ezlibproxy1.ntu.edu.sg/content/334/6057/760.1

    ReplyDelete
  4. Coping with uncertainties can also be regarded as opportunities that can test our capabilities.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This article was written by a real thinking writer. I agree many of the with the solid points made by the writer. I’ll be back.bus charter Los Angeles

    ReplyDelete
  6. There are so many different prospects when it comes to this subject. Thanks for sharing your knowledge on this particular aspect and making it easier for us.best chewable vitamin c

    ReplyDelete
  7. The very next time I read a blog, Hopefully it won’t fail me just as much as this particular one. After all, Yes, it was my choice to read through, nonetheless I genuinely believed you would probably have something helpful to talk about.best vitamins for acne

    ReplyDelete
  8. Although many paperwork which have been key resources continue in non public arms, the typical location for the children can be an save. These types of is usually community as well as nonpublic.http://www.sysintellects.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. captured with the piece of resources you have got here. around on Yahoo News. Do you have any suggestions.patent services Miami

    ReplyDelete
  10. It was wondering if I could use this write-up on my other website, I will link it back to your website though.Great Thanks.how to send money overseas

    ReplyDelete
  11. It is imperative that we read blog post very carefully. I am already done it and find that this post is really amazing.feather bowtie

    ReplyDelete
  12. I am simply pretty happy to check in one’s own guestbook currently, Your own feedback and listed below square measure glorious in my opinion, incidentally I ought to say conjointly positively can teach some nice supplements for your wants each. restaurant hood cleaning

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thank you for benefiting from time to focus on this kind of, I feel firmly about it and also really like comprehending far more with this particular subject matter. In case doable, when you get know-how, is it possible to thoughts modernizing your site together with far more details? It’s extremely useful to me.compare conveyancing quote

    ReplyDelete
  14. I really appreciate the kind of topics you post here. Thanks for sharing us a great information that is actually helpful. Good day!money transfer rates

    ReplyDelete
  15. Good blog post. I want to thank you for interesting and helpful information and I like your point of view. Thank you!vintage clothing online

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thanks for the data and details. You provided meals for believed.oven cleaning

    ReplyDelete
  17. Keep up the good work , I read few posts on this web site and I conceive that your blog is very interesting and has sets of fantastic information.when should you refinance

    ReplyDelete
  18. I was reading some of your content on this website and I conceive this internet site is really informative ! Keep on putting up.Wizz Air

    ReplyDelete
  19. I can see that you are an expert at your field! I am launching a website soon, and your information will be very useful for me.. Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success in your business.Luxury Limo Rental Atlanta

    ReplyDelete
  20. This short article is perfect! If just one had been to purchase an argument on the authentication of this post, I believe that you would have to throw of your energy because this article is ideal in addition to every individual understands this kind of.cape breton real estate

    ReplyDelete
  21. You have done a great job. I will definitely dig it and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site.minneapolis wordpress help

    ReplyDelete
  22. I really love to read this post and I am glad to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Thanks and Regards.breast augmentation dallas

    ReplyDelete
  23. This content is simply exciting and creative. I have been deciding on a institutional move and this has helped me with one aspect.rodent pest control

    ReplyDelete
  24. Not more longing to become popular at present. Buy Facebook Followers as a way to obtain fame and acceptance on the internet in a small duration.mtn data plans

    ReplyDelete
  25. It was wondering if I could use this write-up on my other website, I will link it back to your website though.Great Thanks.www.funwirks.com/couples-costumes.html

    ReplyDelete
  26. Here i found nice environment to get new ideas and views and the i have read the comments of this blog and these are really nice and it is glad to comment here.can get diseases

    ReplyDelete
  27. Wow! Such an amazing and helpful post this is. I really really love it. It's so good and so awesome. I am just amazed. I hope that you continue to do your work like this in the future also.plastic cards printers

    ReplyDelete
  28. This posting is marvelous and what a fantastic research that you have done. It has helped me a lot. thank you very much.tree service suffolk county

    ReplyDelete
  29. Is called to be like this blog ya, always present a variety of current information, actual and informative. Everything should imitate this extraordinary site.arborists of long island

    ReplyDelete
  30. Shen Tong is an Angel Investor and has invested in plenty of start-ups related to the food industry. Shen Tong is an entrepreneur and is extensively involved in the media industry and software industry. Shen Tong is the founder and president of VFinity and is also in the board of directors of Food Tank. VFinity essentially is responsible for making web applications for multimedia and multilingual search, software tools, media production, archiving, and media distribution. Shen Tong is widely acknowledged because of the speech he made on the promotion of context media and suppression of the National Association of Broadcasters in Las Vegas. Apart from being a sequential entrepreneur, Shen Tong is a writer/poet, social activist, a film buff and a foodie. Shen Tong holds an honorary Ph.D. degree from St Ambrose University. It was in the year 2000 when Shen Tong moved to the city of New York and founded business accelerators: FoodFutureCo in the year 2015 and Food-X in the year 2014.Shen Tong co-chaired a committee designed to form a dialogue concerning the Chinese pro-democracy movement.Shen Tong organised the democracy movement in 1989 that occupied Tiananmen Square while he was at Beijing University.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Had a rough day at work? Don't stress out anymore. It's time you kill your weekend blues anytime anywhere. Whether you have a friend along or a group of professional colleagues, with the all-new Boozeey app, you can locate the best pubs in Delhi . Is it the month end? Need an offer you can't refuse? Don't worry! With Boozey, finding the best pubs in Delhi and the best deals on drinks is just a click away. Boozeey shows you all the listed places with ratings for you to take an informed decision. Regardless of it being big or small, official or an unofficial after-party or even a date with your bae for all you party lovers out there, Boozeey is the perfect app guiding you to the best party experience ever. Boozeey is the app for you, guaranteeing, you and your fellas a great time.

    To know more about Boozeey visit the given link -
    Boozeey

    ReplyDelete
  32. Had a rough day at work? Don't stress out anymore. It's time you kill your weekend blues anytime anywhere. Whether you have a friend along or a group of professional colleagues, with the all-new Boozeey app, you can locate the best pubs in Delhi . Is it the month end? Need an offer you can't refuse? Don't worry! With Boozey, finding the best pubs in Delhi and the best deals on drinks is just a click away. Boozeey shows you all the listed places with ratings for you to take an informed decision. Regardless of it being big or small, official or an unofficial after-party or even a date with your bae for all you party lovers out there, Boozeey is the perfect app guiding you to the best party experience ever. Boozeey is the app for you, guaranteeing, you and your fellas a great time.

    To know more about Boozeey visit the given link -
    Boozeey.com


    Connect to Boozeey through given links:
    Facebook- https://www.facebook.com/boozeey/

    Instagram- https://www.instagram.com/helloboozeey

    Reddit- https://www.reddit.com/user/boozeey




    ReplyDelete
  33. افضل واقوى الخدمات الخاصة بأعمال نقل العفش والاثاث بجدة يقدمها موقع خدماتي تحت مسمى افضل شركات نقل العفش بجدة متميزة ومضمونة وتقدم خدماتها باحترافية عالية وتعتبر شركتنا من افضل واقوى شركات نقل العفش بجده متميزة ومضمونة وتعتمد على عمالة احترافية

    ReplyDelete