Monday, September 26, 2011

High-frequency trading, the downside -- Part II

In this post I'm going to look a little further at Andrew Haldane's recent Bank of England speech on high-frequency trading. In Part I of this post I explored the first part of the speech which looked at evidence that HFT has indeed lowered bid-ask spreads over the past decade, but also seems to have brought about an increase in volatility. Not surprisingly, one measure doesn't even begin to tell the story of how HFT is changing the markets. Haldane explores this further in the second part of the speech, but also considers in a little more detail where this volatility comes from.

In well known study back in 1999, physicist Parameswaran Gopikrishnan and colleagues (from Gene Stanley's group in Boston) undertook what was then the most detailed look at market fluctuations (using data from the S&P Index in this case) over periods ranging from 1 minute up to 1 month. This early study established a finding which (I believe) has now been replicated across many markets -- market returns over timescales from 1 minute up to about 4 days all followed a fat-tailed power law distribution with exponent α close to 3. This study found that the return distribution became more Gaussian for times longer than about 4 days. Hence, there seems to be rich self-similarity and fractal structure to market returns on times down to 1 around second.

What about shorter times? I haven't followed this story for a few years. It turns out that in 2007, Eisler and Kertesz looked at a different set of data -- for total transactions on the NYSE between 2000 and 2002 -- and found that the behaviour at short times (less than 60 minutes) was more Gaussian. This is reflected in the so-called Hurst exponent H having an estimated value close to 0.5. Roughly speaking, the Hurst exponent describes -- based on empirical estimates -- how rapidly a time series tends to wander away from its current value with increasing time. Calculate the root mean square deviation over a time interval T and for a Gaussian random walk (Brownian motion) this should grow in proportion to T to the power H= 1/2. A Hurst exponent higher than 1/2 indicates some kind of interesting persistent correlations in movements.

However, as Haldane notes, Reginald Smith last year showed that stock movements over short times since around 2005 have begun showing more fat-tailed behaviour with H above 0.5. That paper shows a number of figures showing H rising gradually over the period 2002-2009 from 0.5 to around 0.6 (with considerable  fluctuation on top of the trend). This rise means that the market on short times has increasingly violent excursions, as Haldane's chart 11 below illustrates with several simulations of time series having different Hurst exponents:


The increasing wildness of market movements has direct implications for the risks facing HFT market makers, and hence, the size of the bid-ask spread reflecting the premium they charge. As Haldane notes, the risk a market maker faces -- in holding stocks which may lose value or in encountering counterparties with superior information about true prices -- grows with the likely size of price excursions over any time period. And this size is directly linked to the Hurst exponent.

Hence, in increasingly volatile markets, HFTs become less able to provide liquidity to the market precisely because they have to protect themselves:
This has implications for the dynamics of bid-ask spreads, and hence liquidity, among HFT firms. During a market crash, the volatility of prices (σ) is likely to spike. From equation (1), fractality heightens the risk sensitivity of HFT bid-ask spreads to such a volatility event. In other words, liquidity under stress is likely to prove less resilient. This is because one extreme event, one flood or drought on the Nile, is more likely to be followed by a second, a third and a fourth. Reorganising that greater risk, market makers’ insurance premium will rise accordingly.

This is the HFT inventory problem. But the information problem for HFT market-makers in situations of stress is in many ways even more acute. Price dynamics are the fruits of trader interaction or, more accurately, algorithmic interaction. These interactions will be close to impossible for an individual trader to observe or understand. This algorithmic risk is not new. In 2003, a US trading firm became insolvent in 16 seconds when an employee inadvertently turned an algorithm on. It took the company 47 minutes to realise it had gone bust.

Since then, things have stepped up several gears. For a 14-second period during the Flash Crash, algorithmic interactions caused 27,000 contracts of the S&P 500 E-mini futures contracts to change hands. Yet, in net terms, only 200 contracts were purchased. HFT algorithms were automatically offloading contracts in a frenetic, and in net terms fruitless, game of pass-the-parcel. The result was a magnification of the fat tail in stock prices due to fire-sale forced machine selling.

These algorithmic interactions, and the uncertainty they create, will magnify the effect on spreads of a market event. Pricing becomes near-impossible and with it the making of markets. During the Flash Crash, Accenture shares traded at 1 cent, and Sotheby’s at $99,999.99, because these were the lowest and highest quotes admissible by HFT market-makers consistent with fulfilling their obligations. Bid-ask spreads did not just widen, they ballooned. Liquidity entered a void. That trades were executed at these “stub quotes” demonstrated algorithms were running on autopilot with liquidity spent. Prices were not just information inefficient; they were dislocated to the point where they had no information content whatsoever.
This simply follow from the natural dynamics of the market, and the situation market makers find themselves in. If they want to profit, if they want to survive, they need to manage their risks, and these risks grow rapidly in times of high volatility. Their response is quite understandable -- to leave the market, or least charge much more for their service. 

Individually this is all quite rational, yet the systemic effects aren't likely to benefit anyone. The situation, Haldane notes, resembles a Tragedy of the Commons in which individually rational actions lead to a collective disaster, fantasies about the Invisible Hand notwithstanding:
If the way to make money is to make markets, and the way to market markets is to make haste, the result is likely to be a race – an arms race to zero latency. Competitive forces will generate incentives to break the speed barrier, as this is the passport to lower spreads which is in turn the passport to making markets. This arms race to zero is precisely what has played out in financial markets over the past few years.

Arms races rarely have a winner. This one may be no exception. In the trading sphere, there is a risk the individually optimising actions of participants generate an outcome for the system which benefits no-one – a latter-day “tragedy of the commons”. How so? Because speed increases the risk of feasts and famines in market liquidity. HFT contribute to the feast through lower bid-ask spreads. But they also contribute to the famine if their liquidity provision is fickle in situations of stress.
Haldane then goes on to explore what might be done to counter these trends. I'll finish with a third post on this part of the speech very soon. 

But what is perhaps most interesting in all this is how much of Haldane's speech refers to recent work done by physicists -- Janos Kertesz, Jean-Philippe Bouchaud, Gene Stanley, Doyne Farmer and others -- rather than studies more in the style of neo-classical efficiency theory. It's encouraging to see that at least one very senior banking authority is taking this stuff seriously.

91 comments:

  1. HFT is mainly the program trading platform which works on the programming languages..The HFT mainly uses C++ for its many projects as it is cheap and offers good performance in trading market..But its important to have complete knowledge to have high performance..

    ReplyDelete
  2. This post has helped me for an article which I am writing. Thank you for giving me another point of view on this topic. Now I can easily complete my article.bus rental Manhattan

    ReplyDelete
  3. Too been entirely clobber telegram devolve. Each sole of us have gotten to struggle fabric-casuals confidential of leg to facilitate regulate resources intensity furnished outcome constant although however receiving compulsory crammers to promote lead washed-up particulars reduce regarding idiosyncrasy further further ease diplomas.Brazil Honeymoon Packages

    ReplyDelete
  4. Spot on with this write-up, I truly believe that this amazing site needs much more attention. I’ll probably be returning to read more, thanks for the info!70s Costumes

    ReplyDelete
  5. It is imperative that we read blog post very carefully. I am already done it and find that this post is really amazing.onlinegevonden.com

    ReplyDelete
  6. This is a amazing inspiring composition.I am gorgeous plenty pleased among your salubrious process.You put truly really cooperative info. Contain it up.50s Dresses

    ReplyDelete
  7. latest techniques of building and have qualified tradesmen to ensure that your job/project is carried out safely.Rockabilly Style

    ReplyDelete
  8. Raspberries, gooseberries, grapes, strawberries, blackberries, and nanking cherries…I share with wildlife and I’m so happy to see bees everywhere this summer!recreation.tips

    ReplyDelete
  9. This is precisely what I am lookng touching deem to place our system to me! Anyone enact skilled few incredible vacancy. The brother is absolutely apropos in ilk to our advice currently, races I am really religious in kind to balance about the image. Blesss amid deem to enormous proceeds.Tampa Personal Injury Lawyer

    ReplyDelete
  10. Great blog. All posts have something to learn. Your work is very good and i appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts.Personal Injury Lawyer Tampa

    ReplyDelete
  11. The explicit vernacular alms orb professes of increasing spree insecurity beside the minion shaft of deceives, introduce how that leverage encourage your lifelike.West Palm Beach Drug Attorney

    ReplyDelete
  12. love all the products but but santa's belly cookies are my favourite.Fertility vitamins supplements

    ReplyDelete
  13. Your site is really nice and unique. This is one of the best ideas that you had come up for the people and I do hope that they can have a better future.Hair growth vitamins supplements

    ReplyDelete
  14. i am a fig virgin... (except newtons - one of God's favorite foods on a bike ride!) i will be trying this though - One question do you peel them before dicing?prepaid cash card

    ReplyDelete
  15. I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand. Unlike other blogs I have read which are really not that good.Thanks alot!Permeable Paving

    ReplyDelete
  16. It is a sexy prominent bauble. My occupation is cute clout pleased negligible your legitimate pointed. You belong fully important information.tree Service Bronx

    ReplyDelete
  17. I can see that you are an expert at your field! I am launching a website soon, and your information will be very useful for me.. Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success in your business.black bow tie

    ReplyDelete
  18. Awesome collection you have really,interesting and informative also,,i liked your blog,,thanks for share the blog!!conveyancing comparison

    ReplyDelete
  19. You have done a great job. I will definitely dig it and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site.pool überdachung

    ReplyDelete
  20. This is a great article thanks for sharing this informative information. I will visit your blog regularly for some latest post. I will visit your blog regularly for Some latest post.cleaning kitchen hoods

    ReplyDelete
  21. Your content is nothing short of brilliant in many ways. I think this is engaging and eye-opening material. Thank you so much for caring about your content and your readers.conveyance fee

    ReplyDelete
  22. I love reading this information on this page because its appealing to my eyes. Thank you for this.satellite internet

    ReplyDelete
  23. Sharing information is one thing but sharing helpful information is really great. Thanks for this.satellite internet

    ReplyDelete
  24. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  25. I am still learning from you, but I am trying to achieve my goals. I certainly enjoy reading all that is posted on your blog. Keeps the information coming.transfer money abroad

    ReplyDelete
  26. This is good site to spent time; I just stumbled upon your informative blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your very well written blog posts. I will be your frequent visitor, that's for sure.transfer money abroad

    ReplyDelete
  27. Your article has piqued a lot of positive interest. I can see why since you have done such a good job of making it interesting.money transfer comparison

    ReplyDelete
  28. This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free.design your own t shirt canada

    ReplyDelete
  29. This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free.t shirts online canada

    ReplyDelete
  30. Easily, the article is actually the best topic on this registry related issue. I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the fantasti c lucidity in your writing. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates.custom t shirt toronto

    ReplyDelete
  31. Find the perfect destination for your dream holidays in Greece and Turkey.Book your hotel room,hostel or private villa among the thousands available and prepare yourself for an exciting and memorable holiday.custom t shirt toronto

    ReplyDelete
  32. Regular practise and careful playing is required to be able to convey and evolve the different themes, rewarding you with that intimate instrument connection that we musicians lust for.sex ejaculation spells

    ReplyDelete
  33. Hi This is exactly what I was looking for. Thanks for sharing this great Information That is very interesting smile I love reading and I am always searching for informative information like this You are bookmarked.mice

    ReplyDelete
  34. I already saw many blogs but I like this commenting platform. Thanks a lot for your guidance and sharing information.mice

    ReplyDelete
  35. This is quite educational arrange. It has famous breeding about what I rarity to vouch. Colossal proverb. This trumpet is a famous tone to nab to troths. Congratulations on a career well achieved. This arrange is synchronous s informative impolite festivity to pity. I appreciated what you ok extremely herePower washing company Canada

    ReplyDelete
  36. This is really a fascinating blog, lots of stuff that I can get into. One thing I just want to say is that your design is so perfect!voodoo magic spells

    ReplyDelete
  37. What a good blog you have here. Please update it more often. This topics is my interest. Thank you.vintage clothing stores near me

    ReplyDelete
  38. I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work.vintage clothing london

    ReplyDelete
  39. its not allowing me to check anything, fields disabled why is that?professional cleaning services

    ReplyDelete
  40. Anyhow, this recipe isn’t going to solve world hunger or save the environment, but it managed to keep me from wasting another package of fish that was probably a day away from limbo.airport car service bridgeport ct

    ReplyDelete
  41. Thank you so much for the post you do. I like your post and all you share with us is up to date and quite informative, i would like to bookmark the page so i can come here again to read you, as you have done a wonderful job.airport car service bridgeport ct

    ReplyDelete
  42. It is imperative that they read weblog post carefully,I would like to thank you for this excellent information!non-camera phone

    ReplyDelete
  43. I read your blog frequently and I just thought I’d say keep up the amazing work!non-camera phone

    ReplyDelete
  44. Thanks a lot for sharing this amazing knowledge with us. This site is fantastic. I always find great knowledge from it.online desk scheduling

    ReplyDelete
  45. If I become a web researcher, I will turn your website into the most best, because your website has a very nice look and also the content very interesting once, the taste for me is here.escort girl paris

    ReplyDelete
  46. Bei uns finden Sie sämtliches Zubehör zum Aufhängen von Bildern. Vom einfachsten Bilderhaken bis hin zur Bildaufhängung mit Diebstahlschutz. Wir als Bilderrahmenprofi haben hier alle Produkte zur Bildaufhängung in einem Shop zusammengestellt.online room scheduling

    ReplyDelete
  47. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  48. I really like the dear information you offer in your articles. I’m able to bookmark your site and show the kids check out up here generally. Im fairly positive theyre likely to be informed a great deal of new stuff here than anyone.office automation software

    ReplyDelete
  49. I am so happy to read this. This is the kind of manual that needs to be given and not the random misinformation thats at the other blogs. Thanks for sharing this.custom tshirts

    ReplyDelete
  50. I am still learning from you, but I am trying to achieve my goals. I certainly enjoy reading all that is posted on your blog. Keeps the information coming.custom tshirts

    ReplyDelete
  51. Hickey “I haven't laughed so hard in years. It's touching, poignant, funny and oh so very real."(DIY) cover

    ReplyDelete
  52. Hickey “I haven't laughed so hard in years. It's touching, poignant, funny and oh so very real."(DIY) cover

    ReplyDelete
  53. Nice to see great write up on your site yet again! Thank you for any other informative web site.We love the site and will come back to see your new posts.Pest Controlperfect golf swing

    ReplyDelete
  54. By praying and trying to hopefully make the best result amen? Thanks be visited this page Securities Attorney

    ReplyDelete
  55. Good morning survived vigorously carry out activities? We will wait for another dish that is very useful.tímová práca

    ReplyDelete
  56. The exceedingly propitious by vile of in request to fervent the concrete computer associated along job promoting. Retain pertaining to tell this share.mortgage broker burlington

    ReplyDelete
  57. Thanks for making the effort to discuss this about Online Ad, I feel strongly about this and love learning more within this topic.t shirt design website

    ReplyDelete
  58. Your blog is really an inspiration to many. I'll be looking forward for more of your posts.Christmas Inflatables

    ReplyDelete
  59. However, the powerful reveals that offer a real value to the market ongoing to flourish and some have now exceeded their pre-recession levels.https://www.aaatreeserviceny.com/

    ReplyDelete
  60. There is a huge craze in the market for these MUVs, I have seen these vehicles in many showrooms. A new car dealership has just launched in our area, I have heard they also have a couple of MUVs in their showroom,zanzibar

    ReplyDelete
  61. However, the powerful reveals that offer a real value to the market ongoing to flourish and some have now exceeded their pre-recession levels. vintage shop london

    ReplyDelete
  62. There was also a component of confusion here to. Would he be able to do these exciting things once again? Or never again?hiring agencies Toronto

    ReplyDelete
  63. I’d ought to speak to the following. That’s not merely one factor I do ! I really like reading through via a publish which can make folks think. Also, appreciate enabling me to look at golf swing trainer

    ReplyDelete
  64. I think this is definitely a great way to create these flyers here. So much that you can get from using and passing out these flyers here. So much good advertising comes from it.best golf swing

    ReplyDelete
  65. Thank you so much for the post you do. I like your post and all you share with us is up to date and quite informative, i would like to bookmark the page so i can come here again to read you, as you have done a wonderful job.cement tile

    ReplyDelete
  66. I'd have to consent with you here. Which is not something I typically do! I enjoy reading a post that will make people think. Also, thanks for allowing me to comment! toronto real estate news

    ReplyDelete
  67. I am impressed by the way you covered this topic. It is not often I come across a blog with captivating articles like yours. I will note your feed to keep up to date with your approaching updates.Just striking and do uphold up the good work. windsor real estate

    ReplyDelete
  68. The only sad part about moving away from Maryland recently, was having to leave ProFIT. Now in my search for a new Zumba class, I am very nervous about what I will find. Alex set the bar very high and now I am expecting, and hoping to find, the same crazy fun she brings to her classes.encaustic tile

    ReplyDelete
  69. Thank you again for all the knowledge you distribute, Good post. I was very interested in the article, it's quite inspiring I should admit. I like visiting your site since I always come across interesting articles like this one.Great Job, I greatly appreciate that do Keep sharing!50s fashion

    ReplyDelete
  70. I am surprised that I like the playstyle, I find it quite intuitive (which might say more about the setup of my mind than the playstyle itself...). And yes, the leap is one of the things which make me love this character so much. Which is why I started a Knight yesterday, because I like to level the mirror-classes side-by-side.Permeable Paving Slabs Jewsons

    ReplyDelete
  71. She was supplying various in call and out call escort in Delhi services for many years to different guys and in the recent times she's become a pro in this specific matter.branson chiropractor

    ReplyDelete
  72. There are thousands of sites on the internet and all in all definitely provide information on the results of each article, but the article on this site different from the others. The article was very detailed and easily understandable.branson chiropractic

    ReplyDelete
  73. Trying away different foldable techniques enables more to suit in your own bag.realty panama city

    ReplyDelete
  74. Awesome and interesting article. Great things you've always shared with us. Thanks. Just continue composing this kind of post.rent apartments panama

    ReplyDelete
  75. You put really very helpful information. I am looking to reading your next post.Things to do in Mostar

    ReplyDelete
  76. I want herringbone floors I want herringbone floors I want herringbone floors. Maybe if I say it enough it'll happen...beautiful!ant extermination

    ReplyDelete
  77. Thanks for the informative blog. The place else may possibly just I get that kind of info written in such a excellent approach? I’ve a venture that I’m just now operating on, and I’ve been on the glance out for such info.boston exterminators

    ReplyDelete
  78. Hi! I found your blog on AOL.Its really comprehensive and it helped me a lot. Continue the good work!tree pruning suffolk county ny

    ReplyDelete
  79. Well I sincerely liked reading it. This subject provided by you is very useful for good planning. tree removal in long island

    ReplyDelete
  80. Sincerely, your post goes to the heart of the issue. I'm not that much of a online reader to be honest but your sites really nice, keep it up! I'm trusting the same best work from you in the future as well. Thanks! can get diseases

    ReplyDelete
  81. Thanks for this awesome information. If you need an attractive website design for your business, visit OGEN Infosystem and also get SEO Services for your business promotion.
    Website Designing Company

    ReplyDelete
  82. Thank you very much for sharing, if you want to buy cheap MUT 20 Coins, please look for our shop: GameMS.

    Madden 20 coins are currently the main trading currency of Madden 20, the most popular sports video game. It is also an essential item for players, but for most players, getting enough Madden 20 coins to unlock player cards is often very cumbersome and time-consuming. It is undoubtedly a very convenient choice to buy cheap MUT 20 Coins at GameMS. At the same time, we not only operate Madden 20, our business scope is very broad, you have a wealth of options, welcome to buy.

    ReplyDelete
  83. Hello everyone , here’s your opportunity for you to achieve your dreams of being a multi million dollar rich through trading , I once loss all I got through trading but was fortunate to come across a woman with great virtue and selfless heart (Mary ) i was introduce to her masterclass strategy while searching online which has revived me of all my losses and made me gain more and more . With her unique strategy you are entitled to daily signals and instant withdraw ,be rest assured of getting a refund of all your loss investment with any platform that has denied you in one way or the other in getting your money . Mr Payton masterclass strategy is simply the best for beginners and those that are finding it difficult to succeed through trading he’ll help you with just a simple step . Email her ( paytondyian699@Gmail.com) .Remember this is absolutely free!!!

    ReplyDelete
  84. Hello everyone, Are you into trading or just wish to give it a try, please becareful on the platform you choose to invest on and the manager you choose to manage your account because that’s where failure starts from be wise. After reading so much comment i had to give trading tips a try, I have to come to the conclusion that binary options pays massively but the masses has refused to show us the right way to earn That’s why I have to give trading tips the accolades because they have been so helpful to traders . For a free masterclass strategy kindly contact (paytondyian699@gmail.com) for a free masterclass strategy. He'll give you a free tutors on how you can earn and recover your losses in trading for free..

    ReplyDelete
  85. Great work man you have post a great post it will help people very much keep it do more for people like that Stars Pay Tribute to ‘Jeopardy’ Host
    .

    ReplyDelete

  86. Thank you for your post. This is excellent information. It is amazing and wonderful to visit your site.You have some quality information here that any reader would enjoy. I got useful information this article.Thanks for this Information.
    Share Market Tips,
    stock Market Tips

    ReplyDelete
  87. A round of applause for your mind blowing article. Much thanks to you. Fantastic.
    hitachi 1.5 ton 4 star inverter ac

    ReplyDelete
  88. It can be intimidating to choose a forex trading platform when you first start trading. A good forex broker should provide security, reliability, one-click trading, trading style suitability, charts, market analysis, good customer support, good bid/offer spreads and a demo account you can try. how to start trading forex

    ReplyDelete