Friday, November 16, 2012

Why time matters

I'm still thinking about the ideas of Ole Peters and the importance difference between time and ensemble averages. A few comments suggest that some people I have "lost the plot," but I'm convinced this issue is indeed extremely important and generally underappreciated. A few things to add for now:

1. This post by economist Lars Syll from earlier this year does an excellent job of laying out the main issues and linking them to the Kelly criterion: a practical criterion for playing risky gambles that is based explicitly on time averages. Lars couldn't have explained the basic ideas more clearly.

2. From some comments on other blogs, similar to some I've seen here, many people familiar with probability theory find it hard to accept that a time average expected return of a random multiplicative process is just not equal to the (usual) expected return of a single round. It isn't. Start with any number you like, multiply it by a long sequence of numbers, each either 0.9 or 1.1 drawn with equal probability, and you will find that the number tends to get smaller. In the limit of an infinite sequence, the result heads to 0. And the result quoted in the Towers and Watson paper, a 1% decline on average per period, is correct.

 3. I came across an interesting comment from Tim Johnson, writing on Rick Bookstaber's blog:
The model Peters develops appears to be remarkably similar to the one Durand proposed in 1957 (The Journal of Finance, 12, 348–363) and is discussed by Szezkely and Richards (The American Statistician, 2004, Vol. 58, No. 3).

I do not disagree with your assessment that there has been an error in economics for the past 77 years (just one?) but mathematicians working in finance have generally ignored Samuelson's attacks on logarithmic utility. Poundstone's book on the Kelly Criterion is a good description of the battle in the 1960s and I there is a rich contemporary literature that develops Kelly's ideas...
The paper by Szezkely and Richards is indeed worth a read, although I'm convinced that Peters has gone considerably further than Durand.

58 comments:

  1. Kelly criterion is the sure way to ruin. Lars assumes he knows the win rate. In reality, nobody knows the win rate. As a result, the Kelly criterion cannot be applied. Your knowledge of probability theory is very weak and so is Lars' because the win rate is already derived from a limiting process, i.e. you cannot go back in time and use the win rate to start with. Who and what can guarantee a win rate of 60% in investment field?

    "From some comments on other blogs, similar to some I've seen here, many people familiar with probability theory find it hard to accept that a time average expected return of a random multiplicative process is just not equal to the (usual) expected return of a single round."

    There is no such a thing as an "expected return of a single round". This is a common misconception of first year math students because of the units of the expected value. The average used in the Towers and Watson paper converged to the expected value only at the limit of infinite trials.

    "Start with any number you like, multiply it by a long sequence of numbers, each either 0.9 or 1.1 drawn with equal probability, and you will find that the number tends to get smaller. In the limit of an infinite sequence, the result heads to 0."

    This is expected, as at the limit the time-average return should converge to the expected value which is also 0. But you insist on defending the Towers and Watson paper in which they assume that in two coin tosses of equal probability one will be a head and the other will be a tail, a gross misconception some high school kids have. In that experiment there are four possible outcomes: (heads, heads), (heads, tails), (tails, tails), and (tail, heads). The average of all those possible time-averages returns is 0 as expected. Is this so hard to understand?

    The problem with most economists is that they do not study probability and statistics and lack understanding of the subject.

    Lars' method is the sure way to ruin. One loser and he is down 20%. Another one and he is down 36%. Another one and he is out of business. It will take only three losers for the average fund to go out of business when using Kelly.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Mark, thanks for pointing to this work. Immediately I myself wrote an article about Peters and ergodicity for the danish newspaper Ingeniøren - ing.dk/artikel/134205 - and also talked with Alex Adamou. Interesting stuff. Sadly, it's in danish.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You guys need to understand probability theory before dealing with this stuff. Apparently, you do not. The notion of risk of ruin is as old as casinos. What you bet is what you can afford to lose. Averages converge to expected values only at the limit, weak or strong. Nobody in the investment industry has ever sized bets based on expected value and this is just a straw man invented by those who do not understand the notion of risk.

      http://www.quantwolf.com/doc/cointoss/cointoss.html

      Risking your entire wealth makes sense only if the probability of win is 1. What you do not understand from this simple result? Anything else is a strawman argument.

      However, even the Kelly criterion is not appropriate when drawdown is used as a performance measure or drawdown adjusted returns are used to rank performance. In that case, you risk what you can afford to risk at every run.



      Delete
  3. Regarding Lars Syll's post I think his equation (7)
    (7) 0.6 log (1.2) + 0.4 log (0.98) ≈ 0.11.
    should read
    (7) 0.6 log (1.2) + 0.4 log (0.8)
    ??

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're right and it has now been corrected (I inadvertently must have read 0.2 as 0.02)!

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
  4. So what? The growth rate was overestimated by a factor of about 5.50. This is finance, right. :)

    This is the least of Lars problems. In general, optimal growth rate is path dependent. His example involved a stationary win rate and equal R:R. These are never true in the investment field.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for give us information about Physics of Finance. Thank you very much.

    ReplyDelete
  6. In regards to 2), a very simple way of thinking about it is to multiply your starting capital (1) by 0.5. If now you multiply your result (0.5) by 1.5, you get "only" 0.75: after a 50% decrease of capital you need a 100% appreciation to get back to your starting point.
    The same holds if first you have a certain % increase of your capital, and then the same % decrease of the increased capital. Your final capital will be lower than the starting one.
    Can be counterintuitive, but if you think about it, it makes perfect sense.
    Andrea

    ReplyDelete
  7. Wow, what a great post. I have been reading such junk lately that this is like a breath of fresh air! I will follow your future posts because I enjoy your style of writing. Looking forward to the next one. friv kizi az

    ReplyDelete
  8. This is an excellent post I seen thanks to share it. It is really what I wanted to see hope in future you will continue for sharing such a excellent post.
    Jakarta Wedding Photography
    Jakarta Wedding Videography
    Bali Wedding Photography
    Bali Wedding Videography
    Wedding Photography & Videography Jakarta Bali

    ReplyDelete
  9. Our commitment is to provide our customers the best shopping experience possible with our personalized customer service at a safe and secure environment. We proudly stand behind the quality of products that we sell because we believe in providing our customers the best quality and affordable fine watches together with excellent customer service
    Online watches Pakistan
    Watches in Pakistan
    Watches prices in Pakistan

    ReplyDelete
  10. This is really an interesting blog I like all the information. Epic Research is one of the best advisory who fulfill your trading requirements.

    ReplyDelete
  11. discipleship programs The C.S. Lewis Institute was founded in 1976 and endeavors, in the legacy of C.S. Lewis, to develop disciples who will articulate, defend and live their faith in Christ in personal and public life.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Park Tao Fenuo uk replica watches on the series of timeless beauty are conveyed to pay a lifetime wish to uk replica watches spend a lifetime, a total of the future of the deep love.uk replica watches presented by Bai Tao Feno on the watches of love long-lasting

    ReplyDelete
  13. We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. Great work
    Assignment Help Singapore World class Online Assignment Help Service Provider. Get first class Assignment Help Services in Singapore of varied subjects with high quality and professionalism. We are offering the services to number of clients from years.

    ReplyDelete
  14. what size dumpster do i need Established in 2003, EnviroSolutions is a vertically integrated solid waste collection, disposal and recycling company located in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic regions of the United States.

    ReplyDelete

  15. Shifts to party [url="https://www.styledress.co.uk/"]dresses online UK[/url]., our women's dresses edit has all the latest trends | Free UK Delivery &

    Returns | Ball gowns to work dresses.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I’m impressed, I must say. Seldom do I come across a blog that’s both educative and interesting, and without a doubt, you have hit the nail on the head. Thank you for providing these details.I will come back to your site and keep sharing this information with us. I blog at Explore Survey where you can win Prizes by taking surveys.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Whenever you need quality Write My Essay For Me Online help, feel free to inquire about our services from our website. One of the benefits you get by paying for our homework help is quality Online Essay Writing Services.

    ReplyDelete
  18. We say NO to confusion and YES to simplicity! Ingramer Instagram Bot Powered By A.I. provides 4 different modules which include all popular features

    free instagram followers instant

    ReplyDelete
  19. Luckily, now you can easily locate a reasonable and dependable longboard with this extensive buyer’s guide. In the end of the buying guide, you would have learned everything there is to know about choosing the most reliable longboards for beginners and even advanced and seasoned users.

    longboarding brands

    ReplyDelete
  20. The anime lovers can use this site at any time in 24 hours. Moreover, it doesn’t matter which country is you. Only you have a stable internet connection and internet supported device to access the site at any time and place

    GoGoanime

    ReplyDelete
  21. Many users of this site think about that either it is safe or not. So, if you think the same query, ten don’t need to worry. The reason is that it is an official site. Also, it is 100% safe and secure for all users.

    Kissanime

    ReplyDelete
  22. Description: The 3M 8822 Cup-Shaped Valved Disposable FFP2 Respirator provides lightweight, effective, comfortable and hygienic respiratory protection against dusts and mists. Traditional moulded shape with nose clip and twin strap design. Comfortable, lightweight and off-the-face design. Durable, collapse-resistant inner shell. This is the valved option. Colour referenced elasticated straps denotes protection level yellow (FFP1), Blue (FFP2) and red (FFP3). This is the FFP2 (blue) version.

    dust mask

    ReplyDelete
  23. As far as the application is concerned, it can be used to clean various appliances such as antiques, work tools, clocks, vehicles, and cookware. For some special needs, you chance its properties with the required process since this is a biodegradable product.

    Calcium Lime & Rust Remover

    ReplyDelete
  24. 예전 실시간게임 은 네임드의 사다리, 다리다리 가 대표적이고 대중적이였다면

    현재 동행복권 게임들이 아주 큰 인기와 사랑을 받고 있습니다.

    파워볼사이트

    ReplyDelete

  25. With more people out and about during the summer months, buy mobile traffic to catch them right where they are at. One of your best prospects might be on vacation standing in a three-hour line at Disney right now waiting to ride a rollercoaster and is killing time getting a jump on their business goals trying to find YOU! All mobile traffic comes from iOS and Android devices. You can even target a category!



    Buy Mobile Traffic

    ReplyDelete
  26. Eyal Nachum is a fintech guru and a director at Bruc Bond. Eyal is the architect of the software that SMEs use to do cross-border payments.

    Cross-border payments

    ReplyDelete
  27. Alleen op die manier kunt u er zeker van zijn dat alles zonder zorgen zal verlopen. Het is dan ook belangrijk om te weten dat wij een specifieke werkwijze hanteren om dit altijd op de juiste wijze te verzorgen.

    Verhuisbedrijf Den Haag

    ReplyDelete
  28. Als u zelf uw kind wil gaan helpen, moet u natuurlijk wel weten wat redactiesommen eigenlijk zijn. Bij redactiesommen zit de som verwerkt in een verhaal. Het worden dan ook wel verhaaltjessommen genoemd. Waar deze verhaaltjes eerst nog vrij eenvoudig en kort zijn, worden de redactiesommen in groep 8 steeds ingewikkelder.

    redactiesommen

    ReplyDelete
  29. Een partytent huren voor je feest heeft verschillende voordelen. Het belangrijkste voordeel is dat je feest ook kan doorgaan als het weer niet helemaal meewerkt. Door een partytent te huren heb je geen last van regen of kou. Het enige waar je rekening mee moet houden is dat er geen al te harde wind staat, want dan kan het gebruik van een partytent gevaarlijk zijn. Je kunt bij Colors Events verschillende soorten partytenten huren waarmee jouw feest of evenement gegarandeerd een succes wordt.

    Lees meer

    ReplyDelete
  30. Op zoek naar een specialist in SEO in Nederland? Zoekmachineoptimalisatie is de perfecte methode om te zorgen dat jouw website bovenaan de zoekresultaten komt. Het mag immers bekend zijn dat scoren op de eerste pagina, of liever nog: in de top 3, van de zoekresultaten jouw bedrijf flink wat klanten kan opleveren

    SEO Expert

    ReplyDelete
  31. Bijna alle leerlingen hebben wel eens moeite met een bepaald vak. Een klein steuntje in de rug is dan vaak genoeg om het verschil te maken in hun cijfers. Dat steuntje in de rug zijn wij. Excellent Academy beschikt over zeer kundige docenten, die de leerling helpen om net dat verschil te maken.
    bijles wiskunde den haag

    ReplyDelete
  32. Webactueel schakel je in als je een maatwerk WordPress website laten maken wilt. Door een maatwerk website te ontwikkelen is het mogelijk om meer leads te genereren. Daarbij hebben we altijd oren voor de wensen en eisen die jij als ondernemer hebt als het om jouw website gaat. Bovendien gaat het om meer dan alleen een website. Ook het toepassen van de juist online marketingstrategie helpt hier in grote mate bij. Wij kunnen dit allemaal voor je verzorgen.
    Webactueel

    ReplyDelete
  33. Zonder al te veel poespas gewoon een nieuwe, strakke en frisse wandafwerking? Dan is het spuiten van latex muurverf een goede uitkomst. En ook dan moet je bij Latex Spuiten XXL zijn. Het hanteren van de speciale spuiten voor latexverf hebben wij ons in de loop der jaren eigen gemaakt. Door de spuittechniek ontstaat er een egale structuur, die een stuk strakker is dan bij het sauswerk met een traditionele verfroller. Bovendien is de klus een stuk sneller geklaard – ondanks dat we de werkzaamheden minstens zo gepassioneerd als traditioneel binnenschilderwerk uitvoeren. Latex spuiten is daarom doorgaans voordeliger dan latexen met de verfroller. Disclaimer: dit is afhankelijk per situatie en oppervlakte.

    Latex spuiten


    ReplyDelete
  34. pest elimination services removal expert pest control specialists who can tailor their pest control services based on your needs and the needs of your business, employees and customers. We will work with you to create an effective pest control solution for a variety of pests.
    Ants leave a scented trail that other ants follow. Sweeping or mopping isn’t enough to eliminate the scent.Killing the ants passing by will not eliminate the problem from its roots. The main source of the colonies is the queen. In order to find the nest and the queen a trail of ants must be followed. It is important to identify the ants taking food crumbs and following them to find the nest. Once the nest has been found, be careful not to disturb the worker ants taking the food to the nest.
    Sugar ants love a dirty sink and the water you leave them to help wash down the leftovers. Make sure to rinse out any dishes you're going to leave in the sink over night. And when you do clean the dishes, make sure you rinse and wipe down the entire sink to make certain you haven't left residual sweets, food, or moisture behind. If you're really picky about cleaning, you might even want to try pouring a little bleach down the drain to make sure the smell of rotting food doesn't attract more ants to your kitchen. Dish drains should also be emptied and wiped down before the end of the day.
    Little black ants have also garnered the name sugar ant, though their real name is, well, Little Black Ants. Not a lot is known about Little Black Ants, except that they eat just about anything (including other insects) and they really like rotting wood and dark spaces. Getting rid of little black ants, however, despite how little is known about them from a biological perspective, is as easy as getting rid of sugar ants. Sweet baits can be used to control little black ants indoors, and protein baits can be used to control little black ants outdoors.
    Look in attics, bathrooms, and exterior walls. When you find the nest, spray it with an insecticide labeled for indoor use.Trim back bushes, shrubs, and trees that brush against your siding or roof. These provide a bridge for ants to reach your home. Avoid stacking firewood next to the house.


    Exterminators near me


    ReplyDelete
  35. What is the Virus Outbreak Data Network (VODAN)? VODAN is a GO FAIR Implementation Network set up to help fight the COVID-19 Corona virus, that is causing a worldwide epidemic. The Implementation Network VODAN is a step to establish the Internet of FAIR Data and Services. FAIR stands for human and machine-readable digital data objects that are Findable, Accessible, Interoperable and Reusable. Accessibility is fully compliant with regulatory and governance frameworks, including personal data protection and ethical considerations based on the principle to Do no Harm.
    Making data and metadata FAIR ensures that these data are discoverable on the Internet of FAIR Data and Services. Central tot his approach is the establishment of FAIR Data Points (FDPs), for COVID-19 relevant digital data objects. Opening up FAIR (meta)data by publishing them on a FDP allows algorithms to search these (meta)data, looking for patterns. The Internet of FAIR Data and Services is a distributed data discovery network; data are NOT moved, but algorithms going over the internet can find the data.
    VODAN

    ReplyDelete
  36. Fast, reliable virtual business locations tailored to your business needs. Our seamless business integrations enhance your business and profitability.


    virtual business locations belgium



    ReplyDelete
  37. 우리카지노 100%안전 검증된 카지노사이트 만 엄선하여 소개해드립니다 국내 업계1위 우리카지노계열 전통이 있는 온라인카지노 에서 안전하고 편안한 게임을 ..
    우리카지노

    ReplyDelete

  38. Off page SEO alone rarely will allow you to rank for the most competitive of keywords. The best practice is always to implement it in conjunction with keyword focused internal site optimizations.
    We provide affordable Off page SEO Service using white hat SEO tactics to services at affordable rates and committed to promote your website on the top of Google.

    Off-Page SEO Services




    ReplyDelete
  39. Prime Crack is a free site to download 100% working Cracked Software With Serial Key Activator Crack & Full Version Free Download.


    Adobe Photoshop CC Crack

    ReplyDelete
  40. We are one of the UK's Leading Suppliers and Manufacturers of ALL Face Masks. Our range includes all types of Respiratory Protection products meeting various regulations including FFP1, FFP2, FFP3, N65, N95 and N99. Our range includes Valved and Non Valved Respirators, Disposable Dust and Face Masks, Medical, Dental, Hygiene, Surgeons Protective 3 Ply Face Masks. We also stock reusable Face Masks and Respirators


    Face Masks





    ReplyDelete
  41. We have grown into one of the UK's leading suppliers of PPE Personal Protective Equipment, PPE, Face Masks including Surgical, Dental, Hygiene, Medical, FFP1, FFP2, FFP2, N95, N99 and all Respirators plus a massive range of Industrial Supplies with a multi- million pound turnover.
    For more information on our company or a copy of our latest catalogue please do not hesitate to contact us on 01268 768 768, thank you.

    FFP3 Face Mask UK

    ReplyDelete
  42. NEONICE sandals factory specializes in sandals production technology experts, mainly produces PVC, EVA, TPR, PU, rubber and plastic materials such as sandals and flop flops. Starting business since 2008, 10 million pairs of sandals producing and exporting every year. Which can ensure the normal delivery period of each customer. Guarantee quality.

    Our sandals manufacturer focus on custom flip flop, custom sandals, slippers. No matter the color or shape, just need the details of design. We can produce according to your design, or if you don’t have your own design,We can help you make design to help you build your own product on your thougt,too.

    Wholesale Sandals From China

    ReplyDelete
  43. Are You Looking for Financial Freedom?
    Me Too!


    You probably have dreams of a big mansion, and huge ambitions to become successful. You’re willing to do whatever it takes.
    But you’re not oblivious to reality either. You probably know that most of us will never become millionaires.
    There’s so much information out there, you either listen to the wrong people or you get paralyzed by overthinking.
    Before you know it, years would have passed, and nothing would have changed in your life.
    Did I get it right?

    My Millionaire Mission





    ReplyDelete

  44. Thank you for this wondrous post, Great job for publishing such a beneficial web site.
    This is a curation of ongoing and completed COVID-19 Research responses by Kampala International University (KIU). KIU is the number one private university in Uganda and is currently ranked number 4 out of 65 universities in the country according to the January 2020 Webometrics Ranking of World Universities.

    KIU COVID-19 Research





    ReplyDelete

  45. Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts.

    Learning graphic Design Course from the experts helps students to understand products standards tips and tricks which will make them more productive at work, we teach industry standards software such as adobe photoshop cc2020, adobe illustrator cc 2020, adobe InDesign 2020..



    Graphic Design Training Institute


    ReplyDelete