Saturday, December 8, 2012

The Leverage Cycle

My latest Bloomberg column will appear sometime Sunday night, I expect. I wanted to give readers a few links here to various key papers of John Geanakoplos on the leverage cycle, as well as a little further discussion of a few points.

First, this is the most detailed paper Geanakoplos has published (as far as I know) describing the leverage cycle -- the natural feedback process that repeatedly drives economies through cycles in which leverage rises, driving increasing asset prices, and then falls as investors become uncertain, more cautious, and demand more collateral, Prices then crash down accordingly. His argument is that leverage (determined by collateral rates) is a key macroeconomic variable completely independent from interest rates, and often just as important to the economy at large. In particular, increasing (decreasing) leverage is one key direct cause of increasing (or decreasing) prices. As evidence, look at the figure below for housing prices from 2000 through 2009. It shows how the average down payment required for sub-prime mortgages went up and then down, in both cases just in advance of housing prices. (Okay, this isn't proof of a causal link, I suppose, but it's enough to convince me.)



But before reading the "serious" paper I recommend first reading the text of this talk that Geanakoplos gave two years ago in Italy. It's much less formal and makes all the main points in a clear way.

From a practical point of view, I think two things stand out to me in his arguments:

First, given the clear importance of leverage in driving economic outcomes, it is quite remarkable that the Federal Reserve Bank has not in the past made any systematic effort to collect the kind of data it would need to monitor average collateral rates in the economy. Between 2000 and 2005, for example, no one at the Fed was going to banks and collecting information on how much collateral they were demanding when lending. This was just not considered a crucial macroeconomic variable. Judging from the tone in his talk, Geanakoplos finds this pretty amazing too. He mentions that the Fed contacted him in 2008 or so to get hold of data of this kind that he had collected. It seems that the Fed has now accepted the systemic importance of leverage and is seriously considering including leverage as a key variable in future macroeconomic monitoring. Whether banks and hedge funds will be required to report leverage levels, I don't know, but this idea is at least on the table. Good thing, I think.

A second interesting point is one that seems kind of obvious in retrospect. The leverage that drives the rise of prices in Geanakoplos's picture is leverage in long positions, which enables optimistic investors to buy more than they would otherwise be able to buy. Leverage in the opposing sense, short leverage allowing pessimists to speculate on a collapse in the market, would act to depress prices. Hence, it is probably more than a little significant that credit default swaps (CDS) for mortgage backed securities were created in 2005. These most likely acted as a key trigger of the beginning of the crash. As Geanakoplos writes,
In my view, an important trigger for the collapse of 2007–9 was the introduction of CDS contracts into the mortgage market in late 2005, at the height of the market. Credit default swaps on corporate bonds had been traded for years, but until 2005 there had been no standardized mortgage CDS contract. I do not know the impetus for this standardization; perhaps more people wanted to short the market once it got so high. But the implication was that afterward the pessimists, as well as the optimists, had an opportunity to leverage. This was bound to depress mortgage security prices. ... this, in turn, forced underwriters of mortgage securities to require mortgage loans with higher collateral so they would be more attractive, which, in turn, made it impossible for homeowners to refinance their mortgages, forcing many to default, which then began to depress home prices, which then made it even harder to sell new mortgages, and so on. I believe the introduction of CDS trading on a grand scale in mortgages is a critical, overlooked factor in the crisis. Until now people have assumed it all began when home prices started to fall in 2006. But why home prices should begin to fall then has remained a mystery.

...Of course, if CDS were introduced from the beginning, prices would never have gotten so high. But they were only introduced after the market was at its peak.
Not that the crisis wouldn't have happened in the absence of CDS contracts, but they probably hastened the collapse.

Finally, on a related matter, I think many people may find good value in this article by Ray Dalio, head of Bridgewater Investments. This is Dalio's attempt to give a simple explanation of "how the economy works" and he puts the expansion and contraction of credit at the very center. He is essentially making much the same argument as Geanakoplos, but in a less formal way. Fun to read and very instructive, in my opinion.




23 comments:

  1. I have to say this post was certainly informative and contains useful content for enthusiastic visitors. I will definitely bookmark this blog for future reference and further viewing. Thanks a bunch for sharing this with us!
    sell house fast

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love to write about Truyen Sex, but only about things that interest me. Ever since I was a young lil' thing I've had an interest and "talent" for long-winded, hand written letters and journal entries. As technology began to grow so did my writing as it morphed from paper and pen to monitor and keyboard. I wrote huge posts in a few BBSs (pre-forum days) and later typed up a storm in chat rooms, emails, and other online media.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice stuff for my research writing.Wonderful post! This is very useful to many readers like me. Being a student, I am requiring myself to read articles more often and your writing just caught my interest. Thank you so much!
    Become Ordained Online

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nice stuff for my research writing.Wonderful post! This is very useful to many readers like me. Being a student, I am requiring myself to read articles more often and your writing just caught my interest. Thank you so much!
    Find jobs

    ReplyDelete
  5. Excellent read, Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting?I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style.www.crystalapartment.co.uk |

    www.neveschambers.co.uk |

    www.aikosolutions.co.uk |

    www.lewishickey.co.uk |

    www.stadiumcreative.co.uk |

    www.salsagrande.co.uk |

    www.butlerbag.co.uk |

    www.thewatchavenue.co.uk |

    www.artofbrand.co.uk |

    www.bowdennursery.co.uk |

    ReplyDelete
  6. This is an excellent post I seen thanks to share it. It is really what I wanted to see hope in future you will continue for sharing such a excellent post.
    Jakarta Wedding Photography
    Jakarta Wedding Videography
    Bali Wedding Photography
    Bali Wedding Videography
    Wedding Photography & Videography Jakarta Bali

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. We have statistical analysis of financial data for large scale of contraction of credit at the very center. This idea is at least on the table. Good thing,

    ReplyDelete
  9. For the live trading news and significant market updates you can visit Epic Research. It's a big financial advisory firm.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I agree with you. Thank you for sharing the update. It is interesting to have it discussed widely so that we can gain more objective opinions.

    sell my commercial property Coventry &sell my property Notingham

    ReplyDelete

  11. This is a really good read for me.Thanks For sharing.

    Let my Property in London

    ReplyDelete
  12. Your blog keeps getting better and better! Your older articles are not as good as newer ones you have a lot more creativity and originality now keep it up!
    Fully property management Services

    ReplyDelete
  13. Dear Admin,
    This Blog Is Nice Blog Thanks For Sharing
    Why Key To mortgages?
    Here at Key To mortgages
    we are truly passionate about helping people throughout their journey to own their dream home, buy their first investment property, expand their existing property portfolio and protect what’s important to them.
    As a Bournemouth based unbiased mortgage and protection broker, I, Peter Morgan have been advising and working in financial services for over fifteen years. Since then I have been helping people buy property by advising on and arranging their mortgage and associated protection needs.
    I have been successful in helping people achieve their dreams and financial goals for many years. I pride myself on providing outstanding customer service, achieved by working in partnership with my clients, estate agents, solicitors, property surveyors, developers, and lenders.
    At Key To mortgages
    we strive to ensure the buying experience is as smooth and stress-free as possible, allowing you to concentrate on your commitments at work and home.
    We offer a service that many of our clients believe to be second to none. This is proven by our customers returning to us again and again but also by them recommending us to their friends and family.
    key to mortgages Bournemouth
    key solutions mortgages
    best buy to let mortgage
    Interest only mortgage

    ReplyDelete
  14. An industry expert is needed to ensure you secure the best rate, superior care and highest level of service. Listen, don't settle for anything other than a first-rate mover to pack, load and move and store your valuables. Let's look at the benefits of hiring a quality mover: Best Movers Near Me

    ReplyDelete
  15. اقوى الخدمات الخاصة بأعمال نقل العفش مع الفك والتركيب في الرياض يقدمها موقع خدماتي الذي يضم افضل شركات نقل اثاث بالرياض التي تقدم خدماتها بمنتهى الاحترافية والدقة معتمدين على فريق عمل مدرب جيدا ونجارين متخصصين لتقديم خدمات نقل عفش بالرياض باحترافية عالية وجودة غير مسبوقة

    ReplyDelete
  16. افضل واقوى الخدمات الخاصة بأعمال نقل العفش والاثاث بجدة يقدمها موقع خدماتي تحت مسمى افضل شركات نقل اثاث بجده متميزة ومضمونة وتقدم خدماتها باحترافية عالية وتعتبر شركتنا افضل شركة نقل عفش بجدة متميزة ومضمونة وتعتمد على عمالة احترافية

    ReplyDelete
  17. it helps to know what the term means, and to understand the difference between the various types of such mattresses on the market today. reuk mattress

    ReplyDelete
  18. It was wondering if I could use this write-up on my other website, I will link it back to your website though.Great Thanks.



    Really a great post, thanks


    스포츠토토티비
    스포츠중계
    토토사이트

    ReplyDelete
  19. Thanks for showing that kind of knowledge on your portal.You have done all good.I love to see you again with some new content.



    스포츠토토
    메이저사이트 목록
    먹튀검증

    ReplyDelete
  20. 카지노사이트
    안전카지노사이트
    카지노사이트홈

    I cannot thank you enough for the blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Awesome.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I can see that you are an expert at your field! I am launching a website soon, and your information will be very useful for me.. Thanks for all your help and wishing you all the success ..


    온라인카지노사이트
    온라인카지노
    카지노사이트

    ReplyDelete
  22. Self Storage Dubai
    Assuming you are on the chase after a top financial plan storage space in Dubai that wont beg to be spent , we Self Storage Dubai gathered together the least expensive storage spaces in every city in Dubai.

    It is UAE based quickest moving supplies company ( 2 hours conveyance ) moving boxes , freight boxes , air pockets wrap , tape and so forth .

    One of the expert pressing trucking organizations in Dubai. Proficient staff for house moving , office moving , prepared vehicles and constant help in UAE

    ReplyDelete
  23. Hi there excellent blog! Does running a blog like this take a lot of work?
    I’ve very little knowledge of coding but I was hoping to start my own blog in the near future.
    Anyways, should you have any ideas or techniques for new blog owners please share.
    I know this is off subject nevertheless I simply wanted to ask.
    Thank you!

    바카라사이트
    카지노


    ReplyDelete