Wednesday, March 5, 2014

Economists' "just so" stories...


A "just so" story is one that gives a nice comforting but ultimately fantastic explanation for some puzzling and unexplained thing. Rudyard Kipling of course made the idea famous in his book of that name. The Leopard's spots, in his story, were originally painted on by an Ethiopian, after that Ethiopian had first painted himself black.

Modern economists have picked up the ball and now, with their sophisticated Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium models, tell similar just so stories to explain (after the fact, of course) how economies work. It's all comes down to a lot of infinite forward thinking, rational optimization and equilibrium. I do wonder in fact if there is anything that could conceivable happen in an economy that DSGE modellers wouldn't be able to "explain" after sufficient work. Indeed, that would be an interesting exercise for DSGE lovers: can you make a short list of economic happenings that would clearly be inconsistent with your theories?

On a related matter, I think there is something very fishy about economists' defense of DSGE models as being useful for "telling stories." I've heard this excuse several times recently. No, they may not find much empirical support, and no, they're not much good for prediction, and no again, no one on Wall St. uses them in making practical investment decisions. BUT STILL -- these things are really very useful because they let us tell stories about how the economy works. That to me smells rotten.

I've written an essay on these "just so" stories over at Medium.com. I'm experimenting with writing over there a little, and will continue exploring themes relevant to The Physics of Finance. I'll always put a link here so anyone interested can go through. 

12 comments:

  1. I don't think that there are Economists who can really predict the future situation of our economy. Yes! they can predict it but it is a fact that we donb't even know if this would really happen because we are the one who will so it and we are the one who will make our own future. Marketing research services

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is very famous book and i also read this book story and its really nice for kids thanks for share it sop service .

    ReplyDelete
  3. Only a well deserved and fantastic person can write statement of purpose for mba. This is not tricky and just need some reasonable method.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Really impressive post. I read it whole and going to share it with my social circules. I enjoyed your article and planning to rewrite it on my own blog.
    my latest blog post | my latest blog post | my latest blog post | my latest blog post | my latest blog post | my latest blog post | my latest blog post

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you for making me understand about how an expert assist student with Nursing assignment help by going through many writing formats of assignments such as essays, reports, thesis, articles and many more. Likewise, there exist one such company as Online Assignment Expert that provides top quality assignments at affordable prices. We at Online assignment Expert provide world class feature of on-time assignment delivery, plagiarism check, partial payment, unlimited revisions, etc. You can contact our team of highly professional and experienced experts engaged in their respective field. Avail our exclusive discounts on our assignment help Australia by contacting our experts at Online Assignment Expert.

    ReplyDelete
  6. We, at IdealAssignmentHelp, provide exceptional SolidWorks Assignment Help to the scholars residing within the Australia, melbourne,etc we have excelled within the sphere of providing online solidworks assignment help service. we help all those students who need solidworks assignments’. At IdealAssignmenthelp, students will simply convey their requirements and have them fulfilled by highly qualified and skilled subject experts.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Law Assignment Help

    Get the professions writing Assignment papers from the Best Assignment Experts. We provide top-quality Law Assignment Help Online. If you looking best assignment experts for your assignment help? We provide high-quality and free plagiarism assignment services.

    Contact Us: +65-91753078.

    ReplyDelete

  8. I am happy to read your post dear admin and hold the wish to continue the different work sets with great enthusiastic. Exploring most researchable work in not easy for me as our assignment help team is ready to hear your query and provide the sure solution. Call our expert to know more information.

    ReplyDelete
  9. NICE POST. It is so connective. If you want to explore more blog on this topic, visit at sourceessay.com and get free samples from homework help team.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Excellent information providing by your Post, thank you for taking the time to share with us such a nice post. assignmenthelp

    ReplyDelete
  11. There are many solutions for academic writing, but most of them come with a price. sampleassignment.com is your affordable answer to high-quality academic help. We cater to students of all learning levels, from college undergraduates to PhDs. Our team is composed of experienced writers with a diverse skill set, meaning you'll always find the perfect author for your task. If you're looking for professional cheap assignment help in any domain, we've got

    ReplyDelete