Friday, May 10, 2013

What has"econophysics" achieved?




Research in so-called "econophysics" -- the application of ideas and concepts from physics to problems in finance and economics -- tends to be quite controversial. Many economists in particular seem to find it fairly annoying, although quite a few others either work in the area or do work that is closely associated in conceptual terms. Physicists in the area have been criticized on various occasions for being ignorant of prior work in economics (sometimes true), of using less than rigorous statistics (I haven't seen anything convincing on this) and of employing unrealistic models.

There is plenty of uninspiring work in the field, as in any area of science. Out of politeness, and to avoid boring anyone, I won't make a list. But physicists have made quite a number of lasting contributions to a deeper understanding of finance and economics; in some cases, I think, they have helped to change the direction of research in economics. So I thought it might be worth making a short list of the things that I think have indeed been success stories. Here goes:

1. More than anything, physicists have helped to establish empirical facts about financial markets; for example, that the probability of large market returns decreases in accordance with an inverse cubic power law in many diverse markets. This seems to be a universal result, at least approximately. I've written about this work here. Work by physicists has also established other generic market patterns such as the self-similar structure of market volatility. I very nice review of these patterns is this one by Lisa Borland and colleagues.

Now, did econophysicists initiate this kind of work? Of course not. Benoit Mandelbrot found the first evidence for fat tailed distributions in the early 1960s (and Eugene Fama even wrote about that work in his first paper!). But research by physicists has made our knowledge of these empirical regularities much more precise.

2. Physicists have also identified instructive links between markets and other natural phenomena. For example, in the period following a large market crash, markets show lingering activity which follows the famous Omori law for earthquake aftershocks (events become less likely in simple inverse proportion to the time after the main shock). Such connections indicate that the explanation of such market dynamics may well not depend on facts specific to finance and economics; that more general dynamical principles may be involved.

3. Physicists have also helped develop more realistic models of markets, here mostly in collaboration with economists. In the mid-1990s, researchers at the Santa Fe Institute first demonstrated how fat-tailed dynamics could arise naturally in models representing a market as an ecology of interacting adaptive agents. Models of this kind have since become widespread and used to perform some of the most sophisticated tests of policy proposals -- for the idea of a financial transactions tax, for example, as currently planned by the European Commission. For this, econophysics deserves some credit. For a nice review, see this paper by economist Blake Lebaron (I've summarized it here). 

If you doubt that the early work at Sante Fe had a real effect on encouraging this work, pushing the study of computational models of heterogeneous adaptive interacting agents to the forefront of market modelling, take a look at this 2002 review by economist Cars Hommes. As seminal work in this area, he cites papers in the early 1990s by Alan Kirman, by Brad DeLong and colleagues and by the group at Santa Fe which involved a key collaboration between economists and physicists. This work helped kick off, as he describes it, a transformation (still ongoing) of style in modelling markets:
In the past two decades economics has witnessed an important paradigmatic change: a shift from a rational representative agent analytically tractable model of the economy to a boundedly rational, heterogeneous agents computationally oriented evolutionary framework. This change has at least three closely related aspects: (i) from representative agent to heterogeneous agent systems; (ii) from full rationality to bounded rationality; and (iii) from a mainly analytical to a more computational approach...
Hommes makes it sound here as if this transformation and paradigm shift is now widely accepted in economics. I'm not so sure about that as there still seem to be plenty of people eagerly working away on rational representative agent models.

4. Work in econophysics -- through the study of minimal models such as the minority game -- has also revealed surprising qualitative features of markets; for example, that a key determinant of market dynamics is the diversity of participants' strategic behaviour. Markets work fairly smoothly if participants act using many diverse strategies, but break down if many traders chase few opportunities and use similar strategies to do so. Strategic crowding of this kind can cause an abrupt phase transition from smooth behaviour into a regime prone to sharp, virtually discontinuous price movements. 

If this point seems esoteric, one fairly recent study found more than 18,000 instances over five years where a stock price rose or fell by roughly 1% or more in well under a tenth of a second. These "glitches" or "fractures" may signal a transition of markets into a regime dominated by fast algorithmic trading. As algorithms compete on speed, they naturally rely on simple strategies, which encourages strategic crowding. The underlying phase transition phenomenon may therefore be quite relevant to policy. I know of nothing in traditional economic analysis that describes this kind of phase transition or does anything to elucidate the kinds of conditions under which it might take place.

5. Yale economist John Geanakoplos has argued for two decades that a key variable driving major economic booms and busts is the amount of leverage used by financial institutions. It goes up in good times, down in bad. Since the financial crisis, controlling leverage has become a major new focus of financial regulators, and their work may well benefit from physics-inspired models of the dynamics of markets in which firms compete with one another through the use of leverage. A notable study by Geanakoplos and two physicists found that such a market will naturally become unstable as leverage increases beyond a threshold. This boundary of instability is not at all obvious to market participants or made evident by standard economic theories. Such models may well help improve macroeconomic policy and financial regulation (I've written a little more on this here).

6. Physicists have also helped clarify other fundamental sources of market instability. For example, standard thinking in economics holds that the sharing of risks between financial institutions -- through derivatives and other instruments -- should both make individual firms safer and the entire banking system more stable. However, a collaboration of economists and physicists recently showed that too much risk sharing in a network of institutions can decrease stability. (Some discussion of this work here.) An over-connected network makes it too easy for trouble originating in one place to spread elsewhere. Again, this work involves an important collaboration between economists and physicists.

7. On a similar theme, fundamental analysis by econophysicists has examined the relationship between market efficiency and stability. In economic theory, markets become more efficient -- more able to pool collective wisdom and price assets accurately -- as they become more "complete," i.e. equipped with such a broad range of financial instruments that essentially any trade can be undertaken. The econophysics work has shown, however, that completeness brings with it inherent market instability, a possibility never raised (to my knowledge) by standard economic analyses.

8. The complexity of today’s markets makes is essentially impossible for financial institutions to judge the risks they face, as the health of any decent-sized financial institution depends on a vast web of links to other institutions about which little may be known. To improve risk judgement, econophysicists have recently developed a network measure called DebtRank which aims to cut through network complexity and reveal the true riskyness of any particular institution. This idea may also provide a natural means for making markets more stable, for if regulators made DebtRank results public, then anyone would, at a glance, gain a much more accurate view of the true risks associated with any bank. If banks seeking to borrow funds were forced to do so from the least risky banks, systemic instability would be improved. This is, for now, a highly speculative idea, but one that clearly has promise.

So there -- a list of 8 specific areas where I think econophysics has had an important impact on economics and finance. This is, as I said, a very short list, and of course reflects only my limited view. It also reflects limitations on how much I can write in one sitting, as there are clearly other notable achievements such as recent theories of market impact -- here and here, for example -- which make significant steps toward explaining how much prices change when someone sells an asset. I haven't mentioned applications of random matrix theory which cast serious doubt over how much empirical calculations of stock correlations really imply about the true correlations between those assets (undermining Markowitz portfolio theory). Then there's an entire field of work exploring how firm growth rates scale with firm size and what might account for this.

All of which suggests, to my mind, that econophysics has been a very valuable development indeed.

45 comments:

  1. Excellent. It's very good that you posted this summary.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Mark, can you recommend a good primer on this subject, popular science style (like your books)?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous,

    Well, you could try my recent book Forecast which covers lots of this stuff! Otherwise, I don't know of many popular science style works on this topic. The wiki for econophysics lists lots of further reading and some video lectures, but I think some of this will be quite technical to begin with. Another book to try would be Phil Ball's Critical Mass. Phil's a great writer!

    ReplyDelete
  4. It has come to my attention that a solution to the puzzle of why large fluctuations in prices have an inverse power law distribution goes unanswered. This is an easy corollary to the principal result of my 1999 book, Axiomatic Theory of Economics, Theorem 12, the Law of Price Adjustment.

    My theory describes a single instant in time. Of course, instants have the habit of following one another, eventually forming something called history. So it is natural to inquire, not just what the price is at a given instant, but what the distribution of price changes is over history. This I did not do in 1999.

    Addressing this issue requires an additional axiom: the parameter called importance, μ, must have an exponential distribution, exp(-μ/θ)/θ.

    In point of fact, the only restriction that I placed on μ is that it be a positive real number. But negative monotonic distributions with this support and moments of all orders are not that numerous. Why not the exponential? The fact that an exponential distribution of μ implies an inverse power law distribution of price fluctuations is motivation enough for most economists to accept this new axiom, and my other results require only that the distribution of μ be negative monotonic on [0,∞).

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great blog, all posts have something to learn. Your work is very good and i appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts. Keep writing.www.crystalapartment.co.uk |

    www.neveschambers.co.uk |

    www.aikosolutions.co.uk |

    www.lewishickey.co.uk |

    www.stadiumcreative.co.uk |

    www.salsagrande.co.uk |

    www.butlerbag.co.uk |

    www.thewatchavenue.co.uk |

    www.artofbrand.co.uk |

    www.bowdennursery.co.uk |

    ReplyDelete
  6. Mark this is an awesome post for someone like me interested in Econophysics to start with,but many of the links given in the post are not working. please rectify it.Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  7. You have a good point here!I totally agree with what you have said!!Thanks for sharing your views...hope more people will read this article!!!
    Kredit for house

    ReplyDelete
  8. This is a very nice article and gives in-depth information. I am so happy to read this.
    Canadian Package Design

    ReplyDelete
  9. Economics is very difficult subject and this article give me good reading ideas thanks for share it personal statement editing .

    ReplyDelete
  10. We are offering best assignment help in Australia for students studying Australia. We have experts cover almost every sub-segment or branches of assignment writing. Assignment help is one of the major services provided by Sample Assignment c. The world revolves around money and economics seems the main subject of concern to students. Hence, they search for paper writing, essay writing help in order to devote their precious time in other equally important tasks.

    ReplyDelete
  11. A great read for nursing students. But why read tips when you can get your assignment delivered to you? Hi, I am a nursing case study help provider at one of the best assignment writing company, My Assignment Services, and have delivered hundreds of nursing case studies. You too can get nursing assignment help online to get your case study done by a professional writer. We specialise in a large number of subjects and courses in the nursing domain and have given our premier nursing case study help to thousands of students studying in Australian universities. All our solution files in assignment help packages are wrapped in originality, plagiarism free and unique answer files which is joined by a free Turnitin report with every order. Get your nursing case study done by best professional writers at the most affordable price at My Assignment Services.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This post is quite striking and helped me to gain deep understanding of some of my academic topics. I would recommend everyone to choose Assignment Help Australia. You can email us at cs@Myassignmenthelpau.Com or Phone Number: +61-2-8005-8227

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thank you for making me understand about how an expert assist student with Nursing assignment help by going through many writing formats of assignments such as essays, reports, thesis, articles and many more. Likewise, there exist one such company as Online Assignment Expert that provides top quality assignments at affordable prices. We at Online assignment Expert provide world class feature of on-time assignment delivery, plagiarism check, partial payment, unlimited revisions, etc. You can contact our team of highly professional and experienced experts engaged in their respective field. Avail our exclusive discounts on our nursing case study assignment help by contacting our experts at Online Assignment Expert.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Your blog presentations is great and informative. Thanks for sharing!! Assignment Writing is becoming a very stressful task for students. Our Assignment Help experts will surely help you to secure the best grades and enhance your future career life.
    Approach us@ Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  15. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thanks for giving great kind of information. So useful and practical for me. Thanks for your excellent blog, nice work keep it up thanks for sharing the knowledge. Just look at the Assignment help given by the assignment experts. Opting for our essay writing service australia could be ideal for such students and they can get a complete assignment solution.

    ReplyDelete
  17. After reading this blog, I understood how students make mistakes in Assignment. However, the experts of Online Assignment Expert provide unique online assignment help . To students all across Australia. This is ensured by the multi-levels of quality checks that make the assignments error-free. Obviously, the assignments would furnish every guideline of the marking rubric.
    As a student, I have availed off their services frequently as I feel their nursing assignment helpexperts are master at whatever they do. I have observed the kind of precision that they display in their work, thereby providing me with an impeccable assignment.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Gotoessayhelp is a round the clock essay help service which caters solutions request to various subjects’ tools & methodology in a multi environment learning concept for the subjects like clock Assignment Help. We are a renowned service provider of essay assignment help and have been receiving an overwhelmed response globally.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Really Appreciate, This impressive post certainly encourages to choose Assignment Help Services. Get Assignment help services by the best qualified and experienced assignment experts of Complete My Assignment.
    Mathematics Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  20. I loved the article, keep updating interesting articles. I will be a regular reader…know about anveshi jain.

    ReplyDelete
  21. The latest news for nmrc exam is that the nmrc syllabus is now released and available on our website.
    All the candidates who are preparing for nmrc can download the syllabus and should prepare accordingly.
    Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Thank you for sharing this informative post.MyAssignmenthelp.co.uk is giving assignment help to students.we are already trusted by thousands of students who struggle to write their academic papers and also by those students who simply want Online Statistics assignment help to save their time and make life easy.

    ReplyDelete
  23. This post really help me when I was in trouble in my Assignment Help. Thanks for sharing such an informative blog, be continue to write such amazing information. Who can write my essay online?

    Mathematics Assignment Help

    Online Assignment help

    Assignment Help Tutors

    Urgent Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts. If you're looking for CDR Report . You can email us at cs@needcdrreport.com or Phone Number: +61-2-8005-8227

    ReplyDelete
  25. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  26. We provide MYOB Assignment Help facilitate at a value that’s very affordable and students friendly. we forever deliver on time and with no excuses! MYOB has an accounting software system that helps businesses to manage finances, save time, and helps the business stay up to date with regulations and obligations. . Our MYOB assignment help is done in record time and delivered to you before your due date. So if you need and you have get help then don't go here and there you have simply visit our website and contact our expert team.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Excellent information Providing by your Article, thank you for taking the time to share with us such a nice article. Amazing insight you have on this, it's nice to find a website that details so much information about different artists. Kindly visit the LiveWebTutors website we providing the best assignment help services in Australia.

    For More Info: Online Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  28. I suggest all members choose Essay assignment help Australia for the best guideline in your academia. The perfect and expert assistant your requirement and learning assignment project by the university.

    ReplyDelete
  29. The car booking engine is a technological solution to the travel industry united with the API system to provide an integrated system of car rentals. Teamindia Webdesign's developers provide the most innovative and unique car booking system and You will get a complete-featured solution for the car booking engine

    ReplyDelete
  30. justquestionanswer.com provides the best homework writing service to the students. Our expert team is available anytime to help in all academic writings like Dissertation Writing, homework Writing Help, course work, Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete
  31. Thanks for sharing this Information.I also recommend to visit mobile app development company for amazing blogs and app development strategy

    ReplyDelete
  32. KloudWIFI truly believes that reliable, fast networks have been the game changers in driving innovation, productivity and instant collaboration supported by the relentless growth of convenient cloud-hosted applications. Even with a powerful, proven network infrastructure like Cisco Meraki and Ekahau, the end user experience can only be truly optimized by considering all the internal and external factors to the end user experiences. Read more- ekahau heatmapper partner in Hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  33. Top Salesforce Consulting FirmsI really want to appreciate the way to write this article.Salesforce Consulting Company It seems that you are very professional and intelligent on the above topics of writing. What Is Salesforce Trailhead

    ReplyDelete
  34. Such a great piece of content and helpful website! Attractive information on your blog, thank you for taking the time and share with us. Essay writer free online delivers high-quality content related to experience. We have experienced professionals who write my essay for me cheap uk hold highest degree credentials and have vast years of helping the scholars.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Airline Reservation System is the best way to make your travel more popular among the travelers. Travelportalonline offers the error-free Airline Reservation System and Airline API integration system to the travel agents at the best price.

    ReplyDelete
  36. IAS Coaching In DelhiI really want to appreciate the way to write this article.UPSC Coaching In DelhiIt seems that you are very professional and intelligent on the above topics of writing. UPSC Coaching In Mukherjee Nagar

    ReplyDelete
  37. Whenever consumers want to search about travel, they use specific keywords and phrases. One of the most important ways to make use of the internet for travel business is through SEO. In fact, developing a powerful SEO strategy for travel businesses is the best way to ensure a presence in front of potential customers and to get more details about SEO read our blog.

    ReplyDelete